4 of 8

LESSON 5 · Art's Greatest Unsolved Mysteries

Who Paid for This

Each of the eighteen militia members chipped in to be in the painting — and they did not all pay the same; reportedly your spot in the picture matched what you put in. Even so, some men ended up sharp and central while others were half-swallowed by shadow. Legend says the company was furious about it. Historians think that story grew taller with each retelling, since the painting hung proudly in their hall for years.

Rembrandt was a master of light and shadow. He aimed a near-theatrical glow at the captain and lieutenant, then let other figures melt into darkness — the same trick stage designers and, much later, film directors would use to steer your eye. Your gaze lands exactly where he wanted it, and the rest of the crowd hums quietly in the dark.